Garden City Work Rest and the Art of Being Human Summary
See a Problem?
Thanks for telling us about the problem.
Friend Reviews
Reader Q&A
Be the first to ask a question about Garden City
Customs Reviews
Things in favour:
- The layout of the book is artistic. The style isn't for me but what JMC does in writing conversationally he does well.
- In that location are some expert principles throughout e.g. seeking wise counsel.
- JMC affirms the dignity in total-time parenting.
- I loved hearing how JMC spends Sabbath.
- "In the same way, when we live and work, non to get what we tin from others, bu
Things in favour:
- The layout of the volume is creative. The way isn't for me but what JMC does in writing conversationally he does well.
- There are some proficient principles throughout e.k. seeking wise counsel.
- JMC affirms the dignity in full-time parenting.
- I loved hearing how JMC spends Sabbath.
- "In the same style, when we alive and work, non to get what we can from others, but rather to dear and serve them, we're harmonizing with the heart of God himself." (280) I similar this.
Less keen on:
- JMC frequently makes interpretive jumps in his exposition of Bible passages and I find his utilize of Hebrew questionable at times. His arguments seem to be at least partly founded on and fuelled by his own conviction.
- The whole argument seems naïvely heart class and doesn't properly take into consideration those who accept less opportunity.
- Discussion of the Autumn in relation to work should have come up earlier.
- "Finding your calling is about finding your voice - what cuts over all the din and drone of the other 7-billion-plus people on world. The melody and tone that merely y'all can bring to the table." (p73) This strikes me as a very modern, western "I'm special" attitude.
- A lot of mention of "following your middle" which I call back the language of the Bible challenges.
- "I don't think that everything that happens is from God's paw. I would put information technology this way: God is involved in your story to the caste that you open upwardly your life to his authorship." (84) This is a very androcentric view. Passages such as Lamentations three:37–39 and Colossians one:xvi–17 could exist used to claiming it.
- "Get alone, fast, pray, accept a retreat, get camping ground all by yourself, hire a room at a monastery - and listen." (88) Firstly, this is very heart course. Secondly, I don't believe God expects us to extract this kind of information or divine some message that 'this is the 1 thing y'all were born to do'. The alternative is liberating.
- "And so, yous have a calling. There's someone God made y'all to be. Something God made you to do. All y'all have to do is dig it out from under the rubble of your fear and insecurity and upbringing and civilisation and consciousness. Information technology's there. Waiting to be establish." (93) The Bible doesn't call for this kind of introspection (thankfully). This is rooted in the modern Western idea of the 'true you' divorced from external influences/factors.
- There were comments throughout that seemed insensitive or in bad sense of taste.
This book is definitely exterior the genres I usually read, and honestly the writing style is not what I'm used to. I'g not necessarily looking for the best writing ever when it comes to these more than message-driven books, but I'k also not used to reading writing that sounds, at times, more like an Instagram caption.
That existence said, it fulfills on what it'southward trying to practise, makes a lot of good points, while beingness enlightening, encouraging and educational. I imagine people that love these kinds of
[7/10This book is definitely exterior the genres I ordinarily read, and honestly the writing mode is not what I'm used to. I'chiliad not necessarily looking for the best writing e'er when it comes to these more message-driven books, but I'g also not used to reading writing that sounds, at times, more than like an Instagram caption.
That beingness said, it fulfills on what information technology'southward trying to do, makes a lot of practiced points, while beingness enlightening, encouraging and educational. I imagine people that honey these kinds of books will probably enjoy this one more than than I did, simply that isn't to say I disliked this book—I would still recommend it to those interested.
...more thanSome points from the book:
Life isnt' almost trying to catch a break, or shouldn't be. We shouldn't be spending our lives trying to do the least work we can then that we can rest, play, vacation, any. In the get-go, Yard
Some points from the book:
Life isnt' most trying to catch a break, or shouldn't exist. We shouldn't exist spending our lives trying to do the least work we can and then that we can balance, play, vacation, whatever. In the beginning, God made us to piece of work WITH HIM, as partners, to develop His world. The reason that work is frustrating, depressing, any, right at present, is because of sin in our world. Simply we were made to work, and to enjoy work, and his point is to notice something you dear and are passionate about doing, if you can, simply any y'all do, to be your BEST at it, because it matters to God. Not only that, just (and this is a new thought I hadn't heard before) our work here will matter when Jesus returns because believers will live and reign on world with Him. Comer'due south signal is that we demand to be the best carpenter, plumber, accountant, mother, NOW considering we may be using those skills when God renews this world at His return.
Sabbath should be a natural rhythm of our lives. He brings up the point that only slaves work non-stop, without reward, for someone else. And we are not slaves. At cosmos, God put a life rhythm into motion when He chose to rest on the seventh day. Taking regular time that is restful and life giving is something He wants and expects for His people. It's how nosotros become renewed, how we gain perspective, how nosotros connect with God and people. On Sabbath for Comer's family, in that location are no electronics, no production consuming, but fun and rest and family and food (made beforehand). This blazon of Sabbath is something we desire to practice in our family because we need to get better at putting work aside and letting the world get on without u.s.a. to be there for each other.
Overall Garden City had some helpful, intriguing thoughts and ideas nearly piece of work and Sabbath, but like I said, Comer's behavior and personality were difficult for me to work through to take the good that he was writing about.
...more thanI initially would have rated this book lower, just I call back that'southward because I came in with the wrong expectations. I was expecting to become practical communication on how to find my calling (the root of my existential spirals of the by few years). I was expecting this book to say do X, Y, and Z and at present you'll have a better thought of what you want to do with your life. If that's what you're looking for, don Some other dinger from my human JMC. Cannot recommend plenty, specially subsequently reading Ruthless Elimination.
I initially would have rated this book lower, but I retrieve that'south because I came in with the wrong expectations. I was expecting to become practical communication on how to find my calling (the root of my existential spirals of the by few years). I was expecting this volume to say do X, Y, and Z and now you'll take a better thought of what you want to do with your life. If that'southward what you lot're looking for, don't read this.
When I changed my expectations I was able to really understand the purpose of this book. It's not to give advice, information technology's to go you thinking about what piece of work and rest really mean, and why both exist. I loved JMC'south objections to modern culture, and even more and so his challenges to us to accept a different viewpoint. I found his perspective really refreshing and fascinating.
Took me a infinitesimal to finish just it was in function because I was drawn to scripture so much while reading! I don't remember any other book has washed this for me. Some other reason why I loved this book.
JMC really killin' the game out hither. Earned another spot on my favorites list. ...more than
"if your dreams are all most you, so your dreams are way likewise modest."
The volume talks a lot about the importance and significance of Sabbath, and how it isn't merely a set of rules to follow for the
I enjoyed reading this book, and I call up information technology connected to change the way that I view the Biblical narrative every bit a whole, and how u.s.a. humans fit into the story. What does it mean to exist restored as a new creation? It ways that we should live out our lives as the image of God - bringing life, civilization, art, and restoration into the world through pursuing our calling with vigor.The book talks a lot near the importance and significance of Sabbath, and how it isn't but a set up of rules to follow for the sake of post-obit rules. Rather, Sabbath is life-giving and allows us to fully alive out our calling in every area of our lives. It also talks a lot most the importance of our work. What nosotros physically practice matters. Every bit John Mark Comer explains, the initial calling for humanity was to take the wild and waste and work the land. The Biblical narrative begins with a description of a Garden, and it ends with the destination -- a Garden Metropolis that exudes life to all peoples. Our task is to create order out of the chaotic earth (just every bit God created club out of the formless waters in Genesis), and this is done through working equally co-creators with God on this earth.
If you're not sure what you want to practise in life, I would recommend giving this book a read. As I read this book, I was as well simultaneously listening through some BibleProject podcasts which dissected their way through the start few chapters of Genesis. If you lot are open to learning more well-nigh this, I would highly highly recommend this book in conjunction with the BibleProject "Ancient Cosmology" podcast series. Seriously, it has amplified a major paradigm shift in the way that I view God, myself, and the world around me.
...moreI have heard a lot about this book and was excited to read it. It delivers the practical advice and the "theologically rich" but I have to say that it was not exactly what I expected.
I like the message, I like to recollect that everyone has a purpose. It's important that we - and especially all those people who consider themselves superior - admit, that whatever job ane does that contributes to society in any manner, is a good chore, important and worth i
"Who you are matters more than what you lot do"I have heard a lot nigh this volume and was excited to read it. Information technology delivers the practical advice and the "theologically rich" simply I take to say that it was not exactly what I expected.
I similar the message, I like to think that everyone has a purpose. It'southward of import that we - and especially all those people who consider themselves superior - acknowledge, that whatever task i does that contributes to social club in any manner, is a good task, important and worth information technology.
Everybody can practice something meliorate than others and better than other things. You lot only need to discover that something for you lot.
And information technology doesn't matter whether yous are 20-something or thirty-something, you can always effigy out side by side steps and a new direction in your life.
"If it doesn't cost yous it costs someone else."
He does make lots of good points, written in an enlightening and encouraging way, like the importance of work, particularly the piece of work we're not being paid for. Or his idea of "sabbath", to non focus on as well much on what mean solar day it should be and what you are or are not immune to practice equally to your religious behavior just rather just seize the opportunity to not have just a day off but a day of residual. Or consumerism as a mod form of slavery.
And the thought that what you exercise with the money you lot earn is every bit important equally the task yous do.
I appreciate a lot he shares merely I don't hold with all of his behavior.
His thoughts on God'southward original intent for how we're meant to spend our time are new to me, which doesn't have to be a bad matter. But in some manner information technology came beyond somewhat too pushy.
Information technology is a quick read though and delivers a lot. There'due south a reason that narcissists are often depressed while those helping others are the happiest.
...moreIt's great to read a book that articulates beautifully thoughts I've had about work, rest and our calling as humans on this wonderful orb chosen Earth.
I loved this book!
it truly is an overview of what it means to be a human made in the image of God.
added to my favorites list!
I will warn yous in advance that the typeface, page design, and (some of the) writing mode are kind of "hipster theology", but I attest that the content is solid.
(My other favorite on this topic is Mike Wittmer's Becoming Worldly Saints: Tin can You Serve Jesus and Still Enjoy Your Life?, which is slightly more theologically focused)
...more"God works, so we work. God rests, so we rest"
With such a simple line of thought you'd think it may feel repetitive, just I didn't get that at all. Garden City gives a hopeful accept on work that neither glorifies vocational ministry nor allows for apathy. I think that's why I love information technology so much! I felt empowered to exist defended
LOVED!!! Unsure if this is a hot take merely I preferred this book to the ruthless elimination of hurry. I think most of the content can be simplified in this quote from the volume:"God works, and so we piece of work. God rests, so we residuum"
With such a simple line of thought you'd call back information technology may feel repetitive, simply I didn't go that at all. Garden City gives a hopeful accept on work that neither glorifies vocational ministry building nor allows for apathy. I think that's why I love it and so much! I felt empowered to be dedicated to learning/studying in my next flavour of life, and as well pushed to have a high value of sabbath. I'd recommend it to everyone 😌
...more than"Our job isn't to fit into some mold or testify something to the world: information technology's to unlock who God'southward made usa to be, and then go be it."
BUT. Permit's not let our old age and crabbiness overwhelm the review.
Comer has some great things to say about the value of our life and piece of work here on earth and how information technology relates
My daughter said I might enjoy this book, but she also said, "It'south more than for young adults." She also forewarned me most the "conversational" style of the book. That way made it difficult to read, because the large print and frequent spaces made it feel as if I was reading a script for a monologue rather than an bodily volume.But. Let's not permit our onetime age and crabbiness overwhelm the review.
Comer has some great things to say about the value of our life and work hither on globe and how it relates to our ultimate destination. We all need to exist reminded that what nosotros practice MATTERS and we are called to practise it to the best of our ability for the glory of God.
I practise have to object to his criticism of the military—I don't think pacifism is the only option for Christians. And he did criticize God's sovereignty: "Usually information technology's found in hyper-Calvinism." And the other options are ----? God is weak? God is not paying attention? Evil is stronger than God? Pitiful, that won't work.
And I don't desire to hear most how yous brew your coffee. Someone needs to tell this modernistic generation that their fixation of java borders on idolatry!
But I've slipped back into crabbiness. I am thankful for his message, and I do hope it volition inspire and energize immature people to pursue their vocation non for themselves, just for God.
...moreI really enjoyed and appreciated this book for what information technology is. Comer himself admits he is offering very little original thought, but he passes on theology and eschatology and hither-and-now ideals and wisdom he has learned at the feet of bedr
"The Bible opens with God giving humans a vocation, a calling to rule, to expect after his creation and make it flourish, and afterward a long, drawn-out detour through human being history, the Bible ends with that vision finally coming to pass and fifty-fifty going forward." (258)I actually enjoyed and appreciated this book for what it is. Comer himself admits he is offering very piffling original thought, but he passes on theology and eschatology and here-and-now ethics and wisdom he has learned at the feet of bedrock scholars (Heschel, Brueggemann, Willard, Wright, Volf).
This book could (and has, judging by Goodreads popularity) really assist popularize NHNE/Edenic eschatology, a creational work-residue rhythm, and a couple other important streams of thought that haven't seemed to achieve "the church" however.
Pastorally, I could come across the work-residue emphasis actually hitting home with xviii-25 year olds exploring a commencement vocation and 40-50 year olds reexploring vocation.
...moreMy wife and I read "Garden Urban center" together when we found ourselves at a bit of a crossroads. In that setting in item, this volume was truly a gift.
...morethe championship "Garden City" comes from the Genesis-similar linguistic communication used in Revelation to describe what is to come up. essentially, a new Eden. this book is about work and rest and what God originally intended us to do with our time hither on earth. the theology of work, if you volition. John Mark dubs information technology every bit "the art of beingness homo." information technology is a call to be intentional in our wor
oh my word this book is so skillful. once over again, read this because I love John Mark Comer. but I actually had no idea what the volume was about.the title "Garden Metropolis" comes from the Genesis-similar language used in Revelation to describe what is to come. essentially, a new Eden. this volume is well-nigh work and residuum and what God originally intended the states to practice with our fourth dimension here on globe. the theology of work, if you will. John Marker dubs information technology as "the art of being human." it is a phone call to be intentional in our work as we look to the future in anticipation of the resurrection. and the eschatology presented in the last few capacity is quite intriguing.
I went into it without any preconceived notions and was surprised by how rich information technology was. I'd definitely read it again.
...moreWhen I'one thousand not reading, I can be found effectually a tabular array with my family and friends, attempting to learn how to cook, drinking Middle coffee, and walking the family unit dog in the woods. About important, I am husband to T and begetter to Jude, Moses, and Lord's day. ...more
News & Interviews
Welcome back. Just a moment while nosotros sign you in to your Goodreads business relationship.
0 Response to "Garden City Work Rest and the Art of Being Human Summary"
Post a Comment